Systems and Properties in Food Engineering: A Detailed Overview

Every food product you see on a supermarket shelf – from pasteurized milk to canned vegetables – has been through a series of carefully controlled engineering processes. At the heart of designing and optimizing these processes lies a surprisingly simple set of ideas: systems and their properties. These foundational concepts from thermodynamics allow food engineers to isolate what they are studying, measure its characteristics, and predict how it will behave during processing. Without a clear grasp of these basics, scaling up a recipe from the lab to a factory floor would be guesswork.

What is a system in food engineering? 🔗

A system, in the context of food engineering, is a defined quantity of matter or a specific region in space that an engineer chooses to analyze. Everything outside the system is called the surroundings, and the line that separates the two is the boundary. The system, its boundary, and the surroundings together make up the universe for that particular analysis.

For example, consider milk flowing through a heat exchanger during pasteurization. A food engineer might define the milk inside the heat exchanger as the system. The stainless steel walls of the equipment form the boundary, and everything else – the steam supply, the ambient air, the rest of the plant – is the surroundings. This clear separation lets engineers focus their calculations on what matters most: how the milk is gaining heat and whether it reaches the target temperature for safety.

Real vs. imaginary boundaries 🔗

Boundaries in food engineering can be either real or imaginary. Real boundaries are physical barriers you can see and touch – the walls of a mixing tank, the shell of a retort, or the casing of an extruder. These tangible surfaces physically contain the food material and separate it from the external environment.

Imaginary boundaries, on the other hand, are conceptual lines drawn by the engineer for the purpose of analysis. For instance, when studying airflow patterns inside a fluidized-bed dryer, an engineer might draw an imaginary boundary around just a portion of the drying chamber to simplify the math. The boundary can be at rest or in motion, and it is the nature of this boundary that determines what kind of exchanges – energy, matter, or both – can take place between the system and its surroundings.

Types of systems: closed, open, and isolated 🔗

Not all systems interact with their surroundings in the same way. Based on whether matter and energy can cross the boundary, systems are classified into three categories. Understanding these types is critical because the equations used for analysis differ significantly depending on the system type.

Closed systems 🔗

A closed system (also called a control mass) is one where the boundary allows the transfer of energy (as heat or work) but not of matter. The quantity of matter inside the system remains constant throughout the process.

A practical example in food processing is a sealed retort used for canning. Once the cans are loaded and the door is closed, no food material enters or leaves the retort during sterilization. However, steam transfers heat energy through the walls and into the cans. The food inside each sealed can is itself a closed system – it receives heat but doesn’t exchange any matter with its surroundings.

Another common example is a batch mixer with a sealed lid. Ingredients are loaded, the lid is closed, and mixing proceeds. Energy enters or leaves (via the motor doing work and heat generated by friction), but the total mass of the food inside remains the same until the process is complete.

Open systems 🔗

An open system (also called a control volume) freely exchanges both matter and energy with its surroundings. In food processing, open systems are far more common than closed ones. Most continuous processing operations – pasteurizers, spray dryers, evaporators, continuous mixers – are open systems.

Take a continuous-flow pasteurizer, for instance. Raw milk enters one end, gets heated as it flows through, and exits the other end as pasteurized milk. Both matter (milk) and energy (heat from the heating medium) continuously cross the system boundary. Spray drying is another clear example: liquid feed enters the drying chamber, hot air blows in, and dried powder exits at the bottom while moist air leaves from the top. Matter and energy are in constant flux.

Analyzing open systems requires engineers to account for both mass flow rates and energy transfer rates, making the calculations more complex but also more representative of real-world food manufacturing.

Isolated systems 🔗

An isolated system permits neither matter nor energy exchange with its surroundings. In reality, truly isolated systems don’t exist – there is always some heat transfer, however minimal. However, an extremely well-insulated thermos flask containing hot soup comes close to this ideal. For short time spans, engineers sometimes treat heavily insulated systems as isolated to simplify calculations.

In food engineering coursework and problem-solving, the isolated system serves more as a theoretical benchmark than a practical reality. It helps establish baseline principles, such as the idea that an isolated system will eventually reach internal thermodynamic equilibrium where no further changes in temperature, pressure, or composition occur.

Understanding system properties 🔗

Once you have defined your system and identified its boundaries, the next step is to describe the system using its properties. A property is any measurable characteristic that describes the condition or state of a system at a given moment. Pressure, temperature, volume, density, mass, and energy content are all examples of system properties.

Properties are what engineers measure, monitor, and control during food processing. When a food technologist says a pasteurization process must hold milk at 72°C for 15 seconds, they are specifying property values (temperature and time) that define the required state of the system for food safety. These properties are further divided into two fundamental categories: intensive and extensive.

Intensive properties 🔗

Intensive properties are those that do not depend on the size or amount of matter in the system. Whether you have a cup of water or a swimming pool full of it at the same conditions, the intensive properties remain identical.

Common examples of intensive properties include:

Temperature – A pot of boiling water is at 100°C (at standard atmospheric pressure) whether it holds 1 litre or 100 litres. Temperature is the most frequently monitored intensive property in food processing because it directly affects microbial safety, enzyme activity, and reaction rates.

Pressure – The pressure inside a pressure cooker is the same regardless of whether you fill it halfway or to capacity. Pressure plays a key role in operations like high-pressure processing (HPP), retorting, and vacuum packaging.

Density – Expressed as mass per unit volume, density is an intensive property because it is a ratio of two extensive properties. Density measurements are routinely used in the food industry to check the concentration of sugar syrups, verify milk composition, and control brine solutions.

Specific heat capacity – This property tells you how much energy is needed to raise the temperature of one kilogram of a food material by one degree Celsius. It is critical for designing heat exchangers and calculating energy requirements during heating and cooling operations.

The practical value of intensive properties is enormous during scale-up. When a food scientist develops a new yogurt formulation in a 5 kg laboratory batch, the temperature and pressure conditions that produced the best results remain the same when production moves to a 5,000 kg industrial vat. Engineers can confidently transfer intensive property targets from pilot scale to commercial scale.

Extensive properties 🔗

Extensive properties, by contrast, depend directly on the amount of matter present in the system. If you divide a given quantity of matter into two equal parts, each part will have half the value of the extensive property compared to the original.

Key examples of extensive properties include:

Mass – The total mass of ingredients in a mixing tank is an extensive property. Double the batch, and you double the mass. Accurate mass measurement is fundamental to maintaining recipe consistency and meeting regulatory labelling requirements.

Volume – The total volume of juice in a storage tank depends on how much juice you have. Volume is an extensive property that food engineers must track carefully, especially when designing storage facilities, piping systems, and packaging lines.

Total energy (enthalpy) – The total thermal energy contained in a system scales with the amount of material. Heating 500 kg of tomato paste requires significantly more energy than heating 50 kg, even though both reach the same target temperature. Calculating total energy needs is essential for sizing boilers, selecting heat exchangers, and estimating operating costs.

Entropy – A measure of disorder or randomness in a system, entropy is also extensive. While less commonly discussed in day-to-day food plant operations, entropy is important in advanced thermodynamic analysis of processes like refrigeration and evaporation.

The relationship between intensive and extensive properties 🔗

There is an elegant connection between these two categories. When you divide one extensive property by another, you get an intensive property. Density, for instance, is mass (extensive) divided by volume (extensive) – the result is independent of system size. Similarly, specific enthalpy is total enthalpy divided by mass. These specific properties (expressed per unit mass) are particularly useful in engineering calculations because they allow comparisons between different food materials without worrying about batch size.

Food engineers rely on published tables of specific properties – specific heat, specific volume, specific enthalpy – for hundreds of food materials. These tables, often compiled by organizations such as ASHRAE and various food engineering research groups, are indispensable tools for process design.

Why these concepts matter in food processing 🔗

Systems and properties are not abstract textbook ideas – they have direct, practical consequences for how food is manufactured, preserved, and delivered to consumers.

Process design and equipment sizing 🔗

When designing a new processing line, engineers begin by defining each piece of equipment as a system and identifying whether it operates as a closed or open system. For an open system like a continuous pasteurizer, mass and energy balance equations are set up around the defined boundary to determine the required flow rates, heating medium temperatures, and equipment dimensions. Getting the system definition wrong leads to incorrect calculations and potentially unsafe or inefficient equipment.

Scaling up from lab to factory 🔗

The distinction between intensive and extensive properties is what makes scale-up possible. Engineers know that intensive properties (target temperature, operating pressure, required density) stay the same at any scale. They then calculate how the extensive properties (total energy input, total mass of ingredients, total volume of product) need to change proportionally. A chocolate tempering process that requires the chocolate to reach 31°C (intensive) will need that same temperature whether you are making 10 kg or 10,000 kg – but the energy required (extensive) scales with the batch size.

Energy efficiency and cost control 🔗

By properly defining systems and tracking energy as an extensive property, engineers can identify where energy losses occur across boundaries. A heat exchanger that is losing excessive energy to the surroundings (across its boundary) can be insulated better, reducing costs. Optimizing each unit operation’s energy use across an entire processing line can lead to significant reductions in operating expenses and environmental impact.

Quality control and food safety 🔗

Monitoring intensive properties – particularly temperature and pressure – at critical control points is the backbone of food safety systems like HACCP (Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points). The temperature of a food product at a specific point in the process must meet defined limits regardless of batch size. Understanding that these are intensive properties confirms that they serve as reliable, size-independent indicators of safety.

State of a system and state functions 🔗

When all the measurable properties of a system have definite, stable values, the system is said to be in a particular state. If any property changes – temperature rises, pressure drops, or volume increases – the system transitions to a new state. The state of a food system during processing is described by a set of properties that are interrelated through what is called an equation of state.

For simple systems like ideal gases, the equation of state is well known (PV = nRT). For complex food systems – which are typically multi-component, multi-phase mixtures of proteins, fats, carbohydrates, water, and dissolved solids – predicting phase behaviour and thermodynamic properties remains one of the main challenges in food engineering. Researchers continue to develop more accurate models that capture the behaviour of these complex food matrices during processing.

A key characteristic of properties is that they are state functions – their values depend only on the current state of the system, not on the path taken to reach that state. Whether you heated milk from 4°C to 72°C slowly or rapidly, the temperature, pressure, and enthalpy at 72°C are the same. This path-independence makes properties extremely useful for engineering calculations. By contrast, heat and work are not state functions; they depend on the specific process path taken.

Equilibrium in food systems 🔗

A system is in thermodynamic equilibrium when its intensive properties are uniform throughout and there is no net exchange of energy or matter with the surroundings. In food processing, achieving equilibrium is sometimes the goal (allowing cheese to age uniformly, for example) and sometimes something to be avoided (you want rapid heat transfer during pasteurization, which requires a temperature difference – a departure from thermal equilibrium).

Food materials are inherently complex. Milk, for instance, is a multi-phase system containing fat globules (liquid/solid), dissolved lactose and minerals (solution), and suspended proteins (colloidal). Equilibrium between different phases in such a system is governed by chemical potential, an intensive property that must be equal across all phases for true equilibrium to exist. Understanding these equilibrium conditions helps food engineers predict stability, shelf life, and quality of their products.

Putting it all together 🔗

The concepts of systems and properties form the foundation on which all food engineering analysis is built. Every time a food engineer designs a heat exchanger, calculates energy requirements for a dryer, or determines the cooling time for a canned product, they are applying these principles – even if the terms “system,” “boundary,” “intensive,” and “extensive” are not explicitly stated.

Mastering these fundamentals makes it possible to approach any food processing problem systematically: define the system, identify the boundary, determine whether it is open or closed, list the relevant intensive and extensive properties, and then apply the appropriate conservation laws (mass, energy, momentum) to solve the problem. This structured approach is what separates rigorous food engineering from trial and error.

What do you think? Can you identify which type of system – open, closed, or isolated – best describes the kitchen equipment you use daily, such as a pressure cooker or an open saucepan? How might understanding intensive versus extensive properties help you when doubling or halving a recipe at home?

References

1. https://phys.libretexts.org/Bookshelves/University_Physics/University_Physics_(OpenStax)/University_Physics_II_-_Thermodynamics_Electricity_and_Magnetism_(OpenStax)/03:_The_First_Law_of_Thermodynamics/3.02:_Thermodynamic_Systems
2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermodynamic_system
3. https://eng.libretexts.org/Bookshelves/Mechanical_Engineering/Introduction_to_Engineering_Thermodynamics_(Yan)/01:_Basic_Concepts_and_Definitions/1.04:_Extensive_and_intensive_properties
4. https://www.ift.org/news-and-publications/food-technology-magazine/issues/2012/october/columns/processing
5. https://www.nuclear-power.com/nuclear-engineering/thermodynamics/extensive-and-intensive-properties/
6. https://pressbooks.bccampus.ca/thermo1/chapter/extensive-and-intensive-properties/
7. https://www.engineersedge.com/thermodynamics/intensive_extensive.htm
8. https://www.aakash.ac.in/important-concepts/chemistry/intensive-and-extensive-functions
9. https://www.sciencedirect.com/book/9780128184738
10. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unit_operation
11. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35571947/
12. https://www.sciencedirect.com/book/9780128115565/thermodynamics-of-phase-equilibria-in-food-engineering